What Are Hijacked Journals?

Avatar photo

Karoline

Most researchers know to be cautious about predatory journals. But there is another, more deceptive threat: hijacked journals. These are fake websites that impersonate real, legitimate journals, tricking authors into submitting papers and paying fees to fraudsters. Some researchers only discover the deception after their work appears on a fake site.

This article explains what hijacked journals are, how journal hijacking works, how they differ from predatory journals, warning signs, how to verify a journal, and what to do if you are affected.

What Are Hijacked Journals?

A hijacked journal is a fraudulent website that copies the name, ISSN, and sometimes the design of a genuine academic journal. The fraudsters pretend to be the real journal, collect manuscripts, and charge publication fees. The papers may then be published on the fake website, but not in the legitimate journal.

Journal hijacking is a form of identity theft that exploits the reputation of established journals.

Hijacked vs Predatory Journals

FeatureHijacked JournalPredatory Journal
IdentityImpersonates a real, legitimate journalUses its own name, often similar to reputable titles
WebsiteFake site copying the real journalIts own website
Main deceptionPretending to be another journalClaiming peer review and quality it does not provide
Risk to authorsPaying fraudsters; paper not in real journalLow-quality publication, little or no review

How Journal Hijacking Works

Targeting Vulnerable Journals

Hijackers often target legitimate journals that:

  • Have no website or a poorly maintained one
  • Publish mainly in print
  • Have recently changed web addresses
  • Have allowed their domain names to expire
  • Are indexed in major databases, making them attractive to authors

Creating a Fake Website

Fraudsters register a similar or expired domain name, copy the journal’s title, ISSN, and editorial board, and design a convincing website.

Recruiting Authors

They send spam emails inviting researchers to submit, often promising fast publication and indexing in well-known databases.

Collecting Fees

Authors are asked to pay article processing charges, often through unofficial payment methods.

Exploiting Indexing

In some cases, hijacked websites have managed to get their content linked in academic databases or search engines, making them appear even more legitimate.

Why Hijacked Journals Are Dangerous

  • Financial loss: authors pay fees to criminals
  • Lost research: papers may not be published in the real journal, and may be impossible to republish elsewhere
  • Career harm: publications in fake journals may be rejected by employers or evaluation committees
  • Damage to real journals: legitimate journals’ reputations suffer
  • Pollution of the literature: unreviewed papers may enter databases

Warning Signs of a Hijacked Journal

  • Unsolicited emails inviting you to publish quickly
  • Website domain names that differ slightly from the official journal’s
  • Promises of very fast review and publication
  • Requests for payment through personal accounts or unusual methods
  • Poor grammar or inconsistent information on the website
  • Editorial board members who are unaware of their listing
  • Different contact details from those listed in trusted databases
  • Claims of indexing that cannot be verified

How to Verify a Journal

Check Trusted Databases

Look up the journal in reliable indexes and databases relevant to your field, and follow links to the journal’s website from those sources rather than from emails or search results.

Use the Hijacked Journal Checker

Retraction Watch maintains a Hijacked Journal Checker, a publicly available list of known hijacked journals and their fake websites. It is a helpful starting point when assessing an unfamiliar site.

Confirm the ISSN

Check the journal’s ISSN through official registries and ensure it matches the website.

Contact the Publisher

Reach out to the publisher or society that owns the journal using contact details from its official site.

Ask Colleagues and Librarians

Librarians and experienced researchers can often help confirm whether a journal is genuine.

An Illustrative Scenario

A researcher searches online for a well-known journal in their field and clicks the top result. The website looks professional and lists the correct journal title and ISSN. After submitting a manuscript, they quickly receive an acceptance email and a request to pay a fee by bank transfer. Weeks later, a colleague points out that the real journal’s website has a different address and no record of the paper. The researcher has lost both the fee and the opportunity to publish the work in the genuine journal.

Scenarios like this show why it is safest to reach a journal’s website through trusted databases or the publisher’s official site, rather than through search results or emails.

How Big Is the Problem?

Journal hijacking has been reported across many countries and disciplines. Lists maintained by research integrity experts have identified hundreds of hijacked titles over the years, and new cases continue to appear. Some hijacked websites have published thousands of papers, showing how many authors can be affected by a single fraud.

Why Researchers Fall for Hijacked Journals

  • The fake site uses the real journal’s name and ISSN
  • Search engines may rank fake sites highly
  • Authors under time pressure may not double-check details
  • Fraudsters promise indexing and impact factors that the real journal genuinely has
  • Some legitimate journals have limited online presence, making fakes harder to spot

What to Do If You Are Affected

  • Stop any further payments immediately
  • Contact the legitimate journal and publisher to report the fraud
  • Inform your institution’s library or research office
  • Report the website to Retraction Watch and relevant authorities
  • Request removal of your paper from the fake site
  • Seek advice before submitting the paper elsewhere

How Journals Can Protect Themselves

  • Maintain an official, secure website
  • Renew domain names well before expiry
  • Display clear warnings about fake websites
  • Monitor for imitation sites
  • Ensure database listings link to the correct website

Tips for Institutions

Universities and research organisations can help by training researchers to verify journals, sharing lists of known hijacked titles, and advising staff not to count publications on fake sites in evaluations without review. Library teams are often best placed to provide this support.

Quick Verification Checklist

  • Did I reach the website through a trusted database or the publisher’s official site?
  • Does the web address match the one listed in reputable indexes?
  • Is the journal on any list of known hijacked titles?
  • Are payment methods official and clearly linked to the publisher?
  • Can the editorial board and publisher confirm the journal’s details?

Taking a few minutes to complete these checks can prevent costly mistakes and protect both your research and your reputation.

Spreading Awareness

Many researchers have never heard of journal hijacking until it affects them or a colleague. Sharing information in departments, discussing warning signs in research training, and reporting suspicious websites all help reduce the number of victims.

Final Thoughts

Hijacked journals are a sophisticated form of academic fraud that exploits trust in legitimate publications. By impersonating real journals, fraudsters collect fees and publish papers without genuine review. Researchers can protect themselves by verifying journals through trusted databases, checking the Hijacked Journal Checker, confirming ISSNs, and being cautious of unsolicited invitations.

Karoline

She is a creative and dedicated content writer who loves turning ideas into clear and engaging stories. She writes blog posts and articles that connect with readers. She ensures every piece of content is well-structured and easy to understand. Her writing helps our brand share useful information and build strong relationships with our audience.

Related Articles

Leave a Comment